| 1 | 24/8/2019 | 52-1 v GresleyGresley 1-2 Sutton Coldfield Town | Emirates FA Cup Preliminary Round |
| 2 | 26/8/2019 | 51-3 v Cleethorpes TownSutton Coldfield Town 1-3 Cleethorpes Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 3 | 31/8/2019 | 5 0-2 v Leek TownLeek Town 2-0 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 4 | 10/9/2019 | 5 3-1 v Redditch UnitedRedditch United 1-3 Sutton Coldfield Town | Emirates FA Cup First Qualifying Round Replay |
| 5 | 21/9/2019 | 51-1 v Kettering TownKettering Town 1-1 Sutton Coldfield Town | Emirates FA Cup Second Qualifying Round |
| 6 | 24/9/2019 | 52-1 v Kettering TownSutton Coldfield Town 2-1 Kettering Town | Emirates FA Cup Second Qualifying Round |
| 7 | 28/9/2019 | 52-0 v Market Drayton TownSutton Coldfield Town 2-0 Market Drayton Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 8 | 5/10/2019 | 50-1 v Boston UnitedSutton Coldfield Town 0-1 Boston United | Emirates FA Cup Third Qualifying Round |
| 9 | 12/10/2019 | 52-1 v YaxleySutton Coldfield Town 2-1 Yaxley | Buildbase FA Trophy Preliminary Round |
| 10 | 19/10/2019 | 54-4 v Loughborough DynamoLoughborough Dynamo 4-4 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 11 | 16/11/2019 | 52-3 v Frickley AthleticSutton Coldfield Town 2-3 Frickley Athletic | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 12 | 23/11/2019 | 52-1 v Newcastle TownNewcastle Town 1-2 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 13 | 30/11/2019 | 52-0 v Wisbech TownSutton Coldfield Town 2-0 Wisbech Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 14 | 3/12/2019 | 50-2 v Market Drayton TownMarket Drayton Town 2-0 Sutton Coldfield Town | Integro League Cup First Round |
| 15 | 7/12/2019 | 50-2 v IlkestonIlkeston 2-0 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 16 | 14/12/2019 | 53-0 v Stocksbridge Park SteelsSutton Coldfield Town 3-0 Stocksbridge Park Steels | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 17 | 21/12/2019 | 5 2-2 v Spalding UnitedSpalding United 2-2 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 18 | 26/12/2019 | 52-1 v ChasetownSutton Coldfield Town 2-1 Chasetown | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 19 | 1/1/2020 | 52-2 v Cleethorpes TownCleethorpes Town 2-2 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 20 | 4/1/2020 | 51-1 v Carlton TownSutton Coldfield Town 1-1 Carlton Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 21 | 11/1/2020 | 5 0-1 v Belper TownBelper Town 1-0 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 22 | 18/1/2020 | 51-1 v Glossop North EndSutton Coldfield Town 1-1 Glossop North End | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 23 | 25/1/2020 | 56-0 v Market Drayton TownMarket Drayton Town 0-6 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 24 | 1/2/2020 | 5 1-2 v Stocksbridge Park SteelsStocksbridge Park Steels 2-1 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 25 | 4/2/2020 | 52-0 v Worksop TownSutton Coldfield Town 2-0 Worksop Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 26 | 8/2/2020 | 53-1 v IlkestonSutton Coldfield Town 3-1 Ilkeston | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 27 | 15/2/2020 | 53-1 v Lincoln UnitedSutton Coldfield Town 3-1 Lincoln United | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
| 28 | 22/2/2020 | 5 1-0 v Worksop TownWorksop Town 0-1 Sutton Coldfield Town | BetVictor Northern South East Division |
