| 1 | Sat 17 Aug 2019 | 51-1 v BuxtonScarborough Athletic 1-1 Buxton | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 2 | Mon 26 Aug 2019 | 170-0 v South ShieldsScarborough Athletic 0-0 South Shields | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 3 | Sat 31 Aug 2019 | 20-0 v Witton AlbionScarborough Athletic 0-0 Witton Albion | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 4 | Tue 3 Sep 2019 | 20-2 v Whitby TownWhitby Town 2-0 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 5 | Sat 7 Sep 2019 | 2 1-1 v Marske UnitedScarborough Athletic 1-1 Marske United | Emirates FA Cup First Qualifying Round |
| 6 | Tue 10 Sep 2019 | 22-1 v Marske UnitedMarske United 1-2 Scarborough Athletic | Emirates FA Cup First Qualifying Round Replay |
| 7 | Sat 14 Sep 2019 | 52-3 v Nantwich TownNantwich Town 3-2 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 8 | Sat 21 Sep 2019 | 72-5 v SouthportSouthport 5-2 Scarborough Athletic | Emirates FA Cup Second Qualifying Round |
| 9 | Sat 28 Sep 2019 | 41-1 v Warrington TownScarborough Athletic 1-1 Warrington Town | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 10 | Sat 9 Nov 2019 | 161-3 v RadcliffeRadcliffe 3-1 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 11 | Tue 19 Nov 2019 | 61-5 v DunstonScarborough Athletic 1-5 Dunston | Integro League Cup First Round |
| 12 | Sat 30 Nov 2019 | 52-1 v Whitby TownScarborough Athletic 2-1 Whitby Town | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 13 | Sat 7 Dec 2019 | 53-2 v Gainsborough TrinityGainsborough Trinity 2-3 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 14 | Sat 14 Dec 2019 | 54-1 v Mickleover SportsScarborough Athletic 4-1 Mickleover Sports | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 15 | Sat 21 Dec 2019 | 50-5 v BuxtonBuxton 5-0 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 16 | Thu 26 Dec 2019 | 21-0 v Morpeth TownScarborough Athletic 1-0 Morpeth Town | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 17 | Wed 1 Jan 2020 | 21-2 v South ShieldsSouth Shields 2-1 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 18 | Sat 4 Jan 2020 | 21-1 v Stalybridge CelticScarborough Athletic 1-1 Stalybridge Celtic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 19 | Sat 11 Jan 2020 | 21-1 v Nantwich TownScarborough Athletic 1-1 Nantwich Town | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 20 | Sat 18 Jan 2020 | 162-1 v Matlock TownScarborough Athletic 2-1 Matlock Town | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 21 | Sat 1 Feb 2020 | 33-1 v Ashton UnitedScarborough Athletic 3-1 Ashton United | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
| 22 | Sat 8 Feb 2020 | 121-0 v Hyde UnitedHyde United 0-1 Scarborough Athletic | BetVictor Northern Premier Division |
Football Web Pages